Ah, the holidays! A time for family, laughter, and, let’s be honest, some questionable culinary choices. Every year, we gather around the table, excited to dig into our favorite dishes, but there’s always that one—or five—items that seem to make their way onto the holiday spread despite no one actually wanting to eat them. You know what I’m talking about: those holiday dishes that everyone feels compelled to serve, yet nobody really enjoys. Let’s take a lighthearted look at five of these perennial offenders.
1. Fruitcake: The Traditional Mystery

Fruitcake has been around since the time of kings, yet somehow, it’s still a holiday staple that few can appreciate. It’s like the sweater your aunt knitted for you — you know it’s made with love, but you’d rather wear a paper bag than sport that thing in public. Seriously, who decided that a dense, sticky loaf of dried fruits and nuts was a good idea? The only thing fruitcake seems to be good for is being re-gifted year after year, or as a doorstop. If you’re still clinging to the tradition, maybe consider a delicious gingerbread or a fluffy cake instead. Your guests will thank you.
2. Jell-O Salad: The Wiggly Wonder
Ah, Jell-O salad, the dish that defies all logic. It’s colorful, it’s wiggly, and somehow, it’s supposed to qualify as a salad? You might find it loaded with mini marshmallows and canned fruit, creating a combination that’s as confusing as trying to explain TikTok to your grandparents. The truth is, Jell-O salad is more of a culinary curiosity than a beloved dish. If you’re looking for something refreshing, why not swap it out for a vibrant fruit platter? Less jiggle, more crunch!
3. Green Bean Casserole: The Creamy Conundrum
Green bean casserole is the dish that shows up at nearly every holiday gathering, almost like clockwork. It’s creamy, it’s topped with crispy onions, and yet, many of us find ourselves pushing it around our plates like a game of vegetable dodgeball. The flavor can be a bit… well, bland, and that texture? It’s like a mushy mystery that no one wants to solve. If you’re determined to have green beans on the table, consider roasting them with some garlic and olive oil for a side that’ll get everyone’s attention—without the casserole guilt!
4. Turkey: The Overcooked Bird
Let’s talk turkey—specifically, the kind that’s dry enough to serve as a substitute for sandpaper. Every year, families lovingly prepare this centerpiece, only for it to end up resembling the Sahara Desert when it’s finally carved. You’ve got to admire the effort, but let’s face it: the turkey often plays second fiddle to the sides. If you’re the one cooking, maybe this is the year to switch things up. Consider a juicy roast chicken or even a beef tenderloin. Trust me, nobody will miss the overcooked bird!
5. The Mysterious Holiday Pudding
Ah, the holiday pudding—often served flambé and laden with dried fruits and spices, it’s one of those dishes that sounds fancy but is really just a dense, slightly sticky mass of regret. This dessert seems to divide families; either you love it or you’re reaching for the chocolate chip cookies you tucked away for emergencies. If you find yourself on the fence about holiday pudding, maybe it’s time to ditch the tradition and try something a little less divisive. A rich chocolate mousse or a classic pie might just win over the whole family!
Making the Holidays Delicious
At the end of the day, the holidays are about coming together and sharing joy, not just food. If you find yourself stuck in a culinary rut with these traditional dishes, don’t be afraid to shake things up! Ask your family for their favorite foods, blend in some new recipes, or even try a potluck style dinner where everyone brings a dish they love. After all, food should be a celebration, not a chore. And who knows? You might even start new traditions that everyone actually looks forward to.
So, this holiday season, let’s raise a glass (or a cup of eggnog) to the dishes we can leave behind, and to the delicious meals that will bring us together. Cheers to a holiday feast that’s not just expected but genuinely enjoyed!
More from Willow and Hearth:
Leave a Reply