We’ve all seen those gorgeous kitchens on social media, right? You know the ones—gleaming countertops, perfectly arranged spice jars, and oh, the open shelving! It looks like a magazine spread, but one woman isn’t buying into the hype. In fact, she’s got some pretty strong opinions about why open shelving isn’t all it’s cracked up to be. Spoiler alert: she’s not a fan.

Meet Sarah, a self-proclaimed kitchen aficionado and a mom of two. Over coffee in her cozy living room, she shared her thoughts on the rise of open shelving kitchens. “I just don’t get it,” she said, shaking her head. “Why would anyone want their clutter on display for the world to see? It feels like a recipe for chaos, not Pinterest perfection.”
Clutter and Chaos: The Realities of Open Shelving
Sarah’s not alone in her sentiment. Open shelving might look like a dreamy design choice, but the reality can be a bit more… let’s say, lived-in. “I’m all for aesthetics, but let’s be real. Do you really want everyone to see your mismatched dishes? Or the half-empty cereal boxes?” she laughed. And she’s got a point.
Open shelving can easily become a display of our not-so-great moments. Unwashed dishes, kitchen gadgets that haven’t seen the light of day in years, and that one pot you swear you’ll use someday—all proudly showcased for guests to see. “It’s like inviting people into your messy closet,” Sarah quipped. “Not exactly the vibe I want for my home!”
Maintenance Madness
Then there’s the maintenance issue. Keeping open shelves looking good can feel like a full-time job. “I mean, who has the energy to dust their plates every week? Not me!” Sarah exclaimed, and I couldn’t help but nod in agreement. With kids running around, the last thing she needs is another chore.
Imagine pulling out your favorite mug for your morning coffee, only to find a layer of dust on it. Gross, right? With closed cabinets, you can hide the chaos and just focus on pouring your caffeine fix. “I like my kitchen to be functional, not just pretty,” she added. And isn’t that what we all want? A little less stress and a little more ease?
Designing for You, Not Instagram
Another point Sarah brought up is how open shelving can feel pressure-filled. “It’s like you’re expected to curate a beautiful display at all times,” she said. For many, that’s just not realistic. Life is messy, and kitchens should reflect that! “I want a kitchen that works for my family, not one that’s just Instagram-ready.”
She suggested that if you’re someone who loves open shelving, you might consider a hybrid approach. “How about a few open shelves for the cute stuff, like your grandma’s vintage teacups or your carefully curated cookbooks? But keep the everyday stuff tucked away,” she recommended. It’s like having your cake and eating it too—show off the pretty things while keeping the clutter under wraps.
The Cozy Factor
Let’s not forget the cozy factor that can come with closed cabinets. “I like the feeling of a warm, inviting kitchen,” Sarah said. “When everything’s tucked away, it feels less chaotic and more like a haven.” There’s something undeniably comforting about a kitchen that feels organized and serene. It’s where we gather, cook, and share meals with our loved ones, after all.
So, if you’re like Sarah and find yourself cringing at the thought of open shelving, you’re not alone. Maybe it’s time to embrace the beauty of cabinets that keep your kitchen tidy and stress-free. Plus, think of all the time you’ll save not having to dust every single dish!
Finding Your Style
Ultimately, it’s all about finding what works for you and your lifestyle. Whether you love the idea of open shelving or can’t stand the thought, the most important thing is creating a space that feels right for you. “Your kitchen should be a reflection of your life, not a magazine spread,” Sarah said. And that’s a message we can all rally behind.
So, the next time you scroll through those perfect kitchen photos, remember Sarah’s words. Sure, they might look dreamy, but that doesn’t mean they’re practical. A kitchen should
More from Willow and Hearth:
Leave a Reply