Holiday decorating has quietly entered its minimalist era, and a lot of the old standbys are starting to look less “festive” and more “why is that still here.” Designers are pushing for homes that feel calm, edited, and personal, not like a seasonal warehouse exploded in the living room. That shift means some once‑popular pieces are now the exact items pros wish would disappear from holiday carts for good.
The good news is that most of these offenders are easy to swap for something more timeless. With a few smart edits, anyone can keep the cozy traditions they love while retiring the decor that drags a room down.
Maxed‑Out Trees, Loud Lights, and Theme Overload
Designers are increasingly blunt about one thing: more is not more when it comes to the tree. Piling on every ornament, ribbon, and trinket until branches sag can make even the most Expensive tree look chaotic instead of special. Pros now favor a tighter color palette and fewer, better pieces so the eye can actually rest. That same “edit it down” mindset is behind the rise of Minimalist trees, where warm white micro‑LEDs and simple ornaments replace multicolored bulbs and novelty baubles.
Those novelty pieces are another sore spot. Designers say a tree covered in joke ornaments and cartoon characters can quickly veer into kitsch, especially when it competes with a mishmash of themes and colors around the room. Experts warn that a living room packed with clashing palettes, Christmas characters, and piles of presents can feel more like a store display than a home. The fix is not to strip away personality, but to be choosy: keep a handful of sentimental pieces and let them shine against a calmer backdrop.
Even when homeowners invest in high‑end decor, designers say the same rule applies. If every surface is covered, the overall effect can still read as cluttered and dated. One report notes that Expensive pieces only look luxurious when they are pared down to a reasonable amount, a core idea behind current Overly Coordinated and minimal trends. Instead of matching every ribbon to every pillow, designers now aim for something that feels intentional but relaxed, with a few standout moments instead of a room full of competing statements.
Plastic, Inflatable, and Faux‑Everything Fatigue
Outside, the biggest offender is the yard that looks like a balloon convention. Oversized Inflatables may thrill kids, but designers like Alex Thies, owner and creative director at Adelyn Charles Interiors, argue that towering plastic characters can instantly cheapen a facade. The same critique hits Mismatched Plast ornaments, which combine clashing styles, materials, or colors and leave a tree looking more like a clearance bin than a curated collection. When every piece is shiny plastic, there is no contrast in texture, so the whole display flattens out visually.
Inside, designers are just as wary of all‑synthetic scenes. All‑White Holiday Trees The trend of fully white faux trees, once seen as chic, is now flagged as one of the All styles that can feel harsh and artificial under regular lighting. Reports on Colored Christmas Trees and a strict Greenery, Only Aesthetic point out that extremes on either side, whether neon hues or nothing but branches, tend to age quickly. Designers now lean toward more natural greens, mixed materials, and a few metallic accents instead of entire trees or rooms locked into a single artificial look.
That same fatigue extends to fake presents and prop‑heavy corners. Stacks of empty boxes wrapped in identical paper, known as Fake Presents Under the Tree, are now called out as one of the more outdated tricks. Designers say they would rather see a few real gifts or a simple tree skirt than a pile of props that never moves. Current guidance on Key Points for holiday styling also urges people to Skip loud themes and Avoid all big‑box trends that rely on plastic volume instead of thoughtful detail. The overall direction is clear: fewer inflatables and fake packages, more real greenery, candles, and textiles that feel like they belong in the home even after the tree comes down.
Bossy Signs, Matchy Rooms, and Visual Clutter
Text‑heavy decor is another category designers are quietly begging people to retire. The once‑ubiquitous “JOY,” “NOEL,” and “Merry & Bright” signs are now cited as Excessive Signage, especially when they appear on every wall, pillow, and mug. Designers argue that if a room already feels festive, it does not need to literally spell it out. One report notes that sometimes signs with text are simply not necessary, particularly when they repeat the same phrases like “joy,” “peace,” and “believe” in every corner. Swapping a wordy plaque for a wreath, a bowl of ornaments, or a strand of garland instantly calms the space.
Visual clutter is not just about words, though. Overly Coordinated rooms, where every item is the same shade of red or gold, can feel as flat as a mismatched one. Experts on Greenery and other staples now recommend a mix of tones and textures so the room feels collected rather than purchased in a single afternoon. Designers also warn against filling every inch of wall space with art, mirrors, and decor. One analysis of Credit and vintage‑inspired pieces points out that when there are too many reflective surfaces or ornate frames, the eye has nowhere to land. During the holidays, layering garlands, stockings, and ornaments on top of that already busy backdrop only amplifies the noise.
Designers are not asking people to strip their homes of personality. They are asking for a little editing so the pieces that matter most can actually stand out. Swapping a yard full of inflatables for a single lit wreath, trading plastic ornaments for a mix of glass and wood, or replacing a wall of slogans with one beautiful garland can make a home feel calmer and more grown‑up without losing any of the joy. In the current wave of Skip and Avoid guidance from pros, the throughline is simple: let the season feel special, not staged.
More from Willow and Hearth:
Leave a Reply