Ah, the magic of Christmas! It’s that time of year when twinkling lights, the smell of gingerbread, and the nostalgia of holiday traditions fill the air. For many, decking the halls isn’t just about the latest trendy decorations; it’s a heartfelt journey back to the past. Enter the world of vintage Christmas ornaments—a treasure trove of memories that collectors are eagerly seeking. If you’ve got a stash of old ornaments hiding in your attic or basement, it might be time to dust them off! Here are seven types of ornaments that collectors are currently shelling out serious cash for.

1. Shiny Brite Ornaments
First up on the list are those delightful Shiny Brite ornaments. Made famous in the 1940s and 50s, these colorful glass baubles are the epitome of vintage charm. What makes them so special? Well, they come in all sorts of whimsical shapes—from traditional round ones to more adventurous designs like birds and snowmen. If you’ve got a box of these beauties, you might find collectors ready to pay a pretty penny for them. Just a tip: Look for the ones with the original boxes; they’re worth even more!
2. Mercury Glass Ornaments
Next are the shimmering mercury glass ornaments, which have a sort of dreamy, ethereal quality. These ornaments date back to the late 1800s and are often distinguished by their silvered interiors. They can be a bit fragile, so if you find any in your grandma’s collection, handle them with care! Collectors love them not just for their beauty, but for the stories they carry. A single mercury glass ornament can fetch anywhere from $10 to over $100, depending on the condition and design.
3. Figural Ornaments
Who doesn’t love a whimsical ornament shaped like Santa, a reindeer, or even a vintage toy? Figural ornaments are incredibly popular among collectors because they add a unique personality to any tree. The charm of these pieces often lies in their quirky designs and bright colors. If you’ve got figural ornaments from the mid-20th century, you could be sitting on a goldmine. Some of these little guys can be worth $50 or more—especially if they’re in mint condition!
4. German Glass Ornaments
Traveling back to Germany, we find some of the oldest Christmas ornaments. German glass ornaments, especially those made in the early 1900s, are highly sought after. They often feature intricate designs, and some even have a bit of sparkle thanks to glitter or other embellishments. Collectors appreciate their craftsmanship and history. You might be surprised to learn that some of these vintage treasures can sell for hundreds of dollars, especially if they’re rare or in excellent condition.
5. Vintage Plastic Ornaments
Now, let’s not forget about the vintage plastic ornaments that really took off in the 1960s and 70s. They might not have the same glassy allure, but these colorful beauties have a nostalgic appeal that’s hard to resist. From shiny, bright colors to funky shapes, they remind many of childhood Christmases. The good news? They’re often more affordable, with prices typically ranging from $5 to $50. So if you’ve got a collection of these, they’re definitely worth showcasing!
6. Hallmark Keepsake Ornaments
Hallmark’s Keepsake ornaments have been a holiday staple since the 1970s, and some of the older editions are starting to gain collector interest. These ornaments often come with great storytelling and character, whether they’re depicting beloved movie scenes or charming seasonal themes. Collectors often seek out specific editions that were produced in limited runs. If you’ve got a few of these tucked away, check the date and see if they’re on the collector’s radar!
7. Handcrafted Ornaments
Lastly, let’s talk about handcrafted ornaments. These are often one-of-a-kind pieces that carry a story in their very creation. Whether they’re made from wood, felt, or even clay, collectors love the charm and personal touch of handmade items. They might not always fetch a high price, but their sentimental value is often priceless. Plus, they add a unique flair to any collection and bring a lovely, personal touch to your holiday decor.
So, if you find yourself rummaging through old boxes, don’t just toss those ornaments aside! You never know what hidden gems you might discover.
More from Willow and Hearth:

Leave a Reply