It starts small, the kind of thing you might second-guess in the moment. You’re telling a story at dinner, offering an opinion at a friend’s place, or answering a question in a group chat that’s gone offline. Then you catch it: the eye roll, the long sigh, the tiny grimace that says “here we go again.”
Later, when you bring it up (calmly, because you’re trying to be chill and not start a thing), your partner insists he didn’t even realize he did it. Meanwhile, a friend has already clocked it, your sister gave you a look, and your stomach did that little drop it does when you feel dismissed in public. It’s confusing, because you’re not asking for applause—just basic respect.
Why this stings more in groups
In private, an eye roll can feel annoying; in public, it can feel like you’ve been demoted. Group settings add a social scoreboard you never asked to play on, where one person’s reaction can quietly influence how others read you. When your partner signals impatience or contempt, it can make you feel exposed, like your words are being put on trial.
And it’s not just about you. People notice dynamics, even when they don’t comment. A partner’s visible irritation can create a weird tension in the room, the kind that makes everyone suddenly fascinated by their napkin.
The “I didn’t realize” defense: possible, but not a free pass
It’s genuinely possible for someone to have unconscious mannerisms—especially if they grew up around sarcasm, conflict, or a family culture where eye-rolling was basically punctuation. Stress, social anxiety, and fatigue can also make people leak emotion through their face and body without meaning to. Some folks are “expressive” in a way that feels harmless to them but lands like a slap to everyone else.
But here’s the catch: not realizing you’re doing it doesn’t erase the impact. If your foot steps on someone’s toes by accident, you still move your foot. “I didn’t mean to” can be true, and it still needs to be followed by “I’ll take this seriously.”
What those gestures communicate (even if he swears they don’t)
Eye rolling and sighing are classic signs of contempt or dismissal, even when they’re subtle. In a group, that can translate as “what you’re saying is dumb,” “you’re taking too long,” or “I’m embarrassed by you.” That’s a harsh message to send about someone you’re supposed to be on a team with.
Sometimes it’s not about the content of what you’re saying, but about control of the spotlight. If your partner gets uncomfortable when you talk confidently or take up space, those micro-reactions can be an attempt—conscious or not—to shrink you back down. If you find yourself speaking less just to avoid his reaction, that’s not a small thing. That’s your social freedom quietly getting negotiated away.
How to reality-check it without turning it into a courtroom
If you’ve only got a vague feeling, it’s easy for the conversation to become “I think you did” versus “No I didn’t.” So get specific. Pick one recent moment, describe what happened, and stick to what you observed: “When I was talking about work at dinner, you sighed and looked away twice.”
If you can, note the social evidence without recruiting a jury. Something like, “I noticed it, and I also saw Emma look at you right after, so I don’t think I imagined it.” You’re not trying to win; you’re trying to establish that this is real and visible. The point is clarity, not humiliation.
What a productive conversation can sound like
Try leading with impact instead of accusation. “When you roll your eyes while I’m talking, I feel embarrassed and dismissed, especially in front of other people.” Then add the request: “I need you to work on not doing that, and if you catch yourself, I’d like you to correct it in the moment.”
If he truly doesn’t notice, treat it like a skills issue, not a character trial—at least at first. Ask if he’d be willing to create a quiet signal, like you lightly touching his arm or saying a code word, to help him become aware without blowing up the room. The goal is to interrupt the habit and replace it with something respectful, like a neutral face, a nod, or just… letting you finish your sentence like a civilized mammal.
Watch what happens next, not what he promises
Anyone can say, “I didn’t realize,” and then move on as if the conversation was the fix. The real test is whether he’s curious, accountable, and willing to practice. Does he ask what it looks like? Does he check in after the next gathering? Does he apologize when it happens, even if it’s awkward?
If he gets defensive, mocks you for being “sensitive,” or turns it into a lecture about how you talk too much, that’s important information. A partner who respects you may feel embarrassed to be called out, but they’ll still care that they hurt you. A partner who benefits from dismissing you will often argue for their right to keep doing it.
When it’s a pattern, not a quirk
Occasional irritation is human. But repeated public disrespect can become a relationship pattern where one person gets to be the commentator and the other becomes the performer who must “earn” approval. If you’re regularly scanning his face before you speak, editing yourself mid-sentence, or feeling anxious before social events, the issue isn’t just an eye roll—it’s the environment it creates.
It’s also worth noticing whether this happens only to you. If he can stay composed with friends, coworkers, and strangers but “can’t help it” with you, that suggests it’s not just unconscious expression. It may be a learned habit of taking liberties with the person he assumes will tolerate it.
Practical next steps that don’t require mind-reading
First, set a clear boundary: “If this happens in front of people, I’m going to pause the conversation and step away, because I’m not going to be publicly undermined.” That’s not punishment; it’s refusing to participate in a dynamic that makes you feel small. Second, propose a repair ritual: if he slips, he follows up with a quick apology and a supportive statement like, “Sorry—go on.”
If this is hard to shift, couples therapy can help, especially because a neutral third party can point out the nonverbal behavior in real time. Therapy also helps separate the surface habit (the sigh) from the deeper trigger (resentment, insecurity, communication differences, or unresolved conflict). And if he refuses to address it at all, you’ve got a different question on your hands: how much disrespect you’re willing to normalize to keep the peace.
What you deserve in the meantime
You deserve to speak in a room without bracing for backlash from the person who’s supposed to have your back. You deserve a partner who can disagree without performing contempt, and who cares about your dignity as much as his comfort. At minimum, you deserve someone who, when told “this hurts,” doesn’t respond with “well, I didn’t notice,” and call it done.
Because even if he doesn’t realize he’s doing it, you’re realizing it. And so is everyone else.
More from Willow and Hearth:
Leave a Reply