It started like a totally normal dog-park afternoon: leash unclipped, the dogs did their happy zoomies, and the humans did that half-wave that says, “I’m friendly, but I’m also watching for chaos.” One owner pulled a small bag of training treats from her pocket, planning to reward her dog for coming when called. Within seconds, another dog trotted over and began vacuuming up the treats like it had found a buffet.
When the treat owner looked up—surprised, not angry—she expected an apology or at least a quick “Oops, sorry!” Instead, the other dog’s owner shrugged and delivered a line that landed like a record scratch: “That’s just how it works here.” The treat bag stayed open, the dog kept munching, and the moment turned into a small but very relatable standoff about etiquette, boundaries, and what “community” is supposed to mean in a fenced-in patch of grass.
A Snack Incident That Turned Into a Social Test
Dog parks are funny like that. One minute you’re tossing a ball and making polite small talk about weather and shedding season, and the next minute you’re negotiating unspoken rules with someone you’ve never met. Treats, in particular, can turn a calm park into a tiny economics experiment: scarce resources, eager participants, and wildly different opinions about who owes what to whom.
In this case, the treat owner said she brought the snacks specifically to practice recall and reward her dog for checking in. She wasn’t trying to host a treat party, and she definitely wasn’t thrilled that her dog’s “payment” was being intercepted by a stranger with four legs and zero shame. The other owner, though, acted as if the snacks were now public property the moment they crossed the gate.
Why Treats at Dog Parks Are a Touchy Subject
If you’ve spent any time at a dog park, you’ve probably noticed that treats are one of those topics that can start a debate faster than “Is that dog friendly?” Some parks discourage treats because they can trigger resource guarding, crowding, or scuffles between dogs that are otherwise perfectly polite. Even dogs who share toys nicely can get weird around food, especially when it’s high-value and coming from a stranger’s hand.
Then there are the health considerations. Many dogs have allergies, sensitive stomachs, or strict diets, and a “just one little treat” can turn into an evening of stomach drama or a call to the vet. Add in the fact that not every owner wants their dog learning that random humans equal free snacks, and you’ve got a recipe for tension that has nothing to do with whether anyone is “nice.”
“That’s Just How It Works Here” (But Does It?)
The phrase “That’s just how it works here” is doing a lot of heavy lifting. Sometimes it’s true—regulars do develop patterns, and in some parks people share water bowls, tennis balls, and the occasional emergency poop bag with a kind of unspoken generosity. But treats aren’t a communal tennis ball, and pretending they are can feel less like community and more like entitlement.
What’s interesting is how quickly “local custom” can be used to shut down a reasonable boundary. The treat owner wasn’t demanding special treatment; she was asking to feed her own dog without being swarmed. If a park really operates on a “food is free-for-all” system, that’s something people should probably say upfront, not after someone else’s dog has already eaten half the bag.
What Most Dog Owners Consider Basic Dog Park Etiquette
There’s no universal rulebook, but most owners agree on a few basics: supervise your dog, clean up after them, and don’t let them bully other dogs (or people). When it comes to food, the common-sense version of etiquette is pretty simple: if it’s not yours, don’t let your dog take it. That includes treats, lunches, strollers with snack compartments, and the mysterious crumbs that appear near benches.
A lot of experienced owners also follow a “no treats inside the fence” habit, not because treats are evil, but because the environment is unpredictable. If you do bring them, it’s generally expected you’ll keep them tucked away and use them discreetly, ideally when other dogs aren’t crowding. And if your dog makes a beeline for someone’s pocket like it’s a vending machine, that’s your cue to step in—quickly and cheerfully.
What to Do If Someone Else’s Dog Is Eating Your Treats
In the moment, it helps to keep it calm and practical. The simplest move is to close the treat bag, put it away, and create a little space—step to the side, turn your body, or move to a quieter corner. Dogs are opportunists, and removing the opportunity often solves the immediate problem faster than arguing over principle while a Labrador continues its snack spree.
But if you do want to say something, short and friendly usually lands best: “Hey, I’m using these for training—can you call your dog off?” or “Please don’t let him eat those; my dog needs them, and some dogs can’t have treats.” You’re not asking for a favor; you’re stating a normal boundary. If the other person doubles down with the “that’s how it works” line, you can repeat yourself once and then focus on your dog rather than getting pulled into a debate.
If You’re the Owner of the Treat-Seeking Dog
Some dogs are basically adorable little snack detectives, and it’s not a moral failing—it’s a management issue. If your dog routinely hunts down other people’s treats, it’s a good sign they need more supervision in high-distraction areas. Practice a solid “leave it,” reward them for disengaging, and don’t be afraid to leash up for a minute if they’re fixating on someone’s pockets.
And yes, it can feel awkward to call your dog away when they’re having the time of their lives. Still, it’s part of being in a shared space. The goal isn’t to run a perfectly mannered dog at all times; it’s to make sure your dog isn’t turning other people’s park time into an unwanted episode of “Snacks Gone Missing.”
When It’s Better to Leave (Even If You’re Right)
Sometimes the smartest move is simply to exit the situation. If a park has a culture you don’t like—whether it’s treat free-for-alls, uncontrolled dogs, or owners who dismiss concerns—it’s okay to decide it’s not your spot. Leaving doesn’t mean you lost; it means you chose your dog’s safety and your own peace over a pointless showdown.
Many owners keep a mental list of backup options: a different park, off-hours when it’s quieter, a long-line session in an open field, or structured playdates with dogs you know. Dog parks are convenient, but they’re not the only way to give your dog exercise and social time. And honestly, the best park is the one where you don’t have to guard your treat bag like it’s a priceless artifact.
A Small Moment That Says a Lot About Shared Spaces
The treat incident is minor in the grand scheme of life, but it hits a nerve because it’s about respect. Most people don’t mind sharing when it’s a choice, and most dog owners are happy to be flexible when everyone’s being considerate. What doesn’t sit well is the idea that someone else gets to decide your boundaries for you, then label it “how it works” as if that ends the conversation.
In the end, dog parks run on the same thing as any community space: a little awareness, a little courtesy, and the willingness to step in when your own dog is the one causing the problem. Treats may be small, but the etiquette around them isn’t. And if your dog ever does manage to score someone else’s snacks, consider it a reminder: being social is a skill—for the humans, too.
More from Willow and Hearth:
Leave a Reply