Willow and Hearth

  • Grow
  • Home
  • Style
  • Feast
CONTACT US
A wooden gavel resting on a dark surface next to a book
Home & Harmony

Couple Prosecuted Over A Veranda And A Backyard Building Added Without Permits Walks Away Without A Conviction After A Judge Finds Their Builder Misled Them

Hire a professional builder, trust them to handle the paperwork, and end up in criminal court yourself. That is what happened to a married couple in Ponsonby, Auckland, who were prosecuted over building work added to their home without the required permits.

A wooden gavel resting on a dark surface next to a book

In a decision reported on November 11, 2026, Auckland District Court Judge Sheena Tepania discharged them without conviction, finding they had been misled by the professional builder they hired, according to a local press report of the case.

A 49.5 Square Meter Veranda And A Two-Storey Backyard Building

Auckland Council brought two charges under New Zealand’s Building Act against the couple, who own a home in Ponsonby. The charges covered two pieces of work added to the property without the required building consents.

One was a 49.5 square meter veranda. The other was a two-storey accessory building of 18.8 square meters. The couple pleaded guilty and asked to be discharged without conviction.

The couple declined to discuss their circumstances, saying the case was a sensitive family matter. They are not named here.

Judge: The Couple Were Misled By A Professional Company

Judge Tepania found the overall gravity of the offending was low. She placed significant weight on the role of the building company the couple hired, Building Brothers Construction Ltd, known in court as BBCL.

The judge said BBCL was a professional construction company, and it was reasonable for the homeowners to expect it would understand the rules about building work and the need to get consents. She accepted that the offending was a product of the couple having been misled by the company.

The couple’s lawyer described them as customers who had become defendants after being “misled by the professional builder they had entrusted with renovating their home.” The homeowners have since taken the steps needed for the work to be remediated and brought into compliance.

Council Argued Heritage Harm And Pointed To The Husband’s Building Experience

Council lawyer Kate Rogers argued that the unconsented additions had the potential to harm the heritage values and special character of the area. She also argued that one of the homeowners was a newly qualified builder who had carried out some of the building work as an apprentice and so had some industry knowledge.

Her argument was that the couple could not completely distance themselves from responsibility, because they had earlier sought consent for major renovations to the property.

The judge found the suggestion that the homeowner’s experience as an apprentice should increase his culpability was “somewhat misplaced.” His experience did not change the fact that the couple were customers who had entrusted the work to a professional construction company.

A Conviction Could Have Cost A Builder His Work

The judge also weighed what a conviction would mean for someone who has since qualified as a builder. She said: “I acknowledge that the stigma that attaches to a conviction is an ordinary and expected consequence; however, given the industry in which [he] works, it is likely that a conviction will directly impact his ability to obtain building work.”

That reasoning helped tip the decision toward a discharge without conviction.

Fines Of $10,000 To $15,000 Were Sought, Costs Of $3,000 Each Ordered

Earlier in the hearing, the council had asked for a starting point for fines of between $10,000 and $15,000 for each defendant. The judge decided instead that each should pay $3,000 to contribute to the council’s costs of the proceedings.

She discharged them without conviction but ordered each to pay a further $152 in court costs. Because this is a New Zealand case, the amounts are presumably New Zealand dollars.

The Builder Went Into Liquidation And Was Never Charged

Companies Office records show Building Brothers Construction Ltd went into liquidation in January. The company’s liquidator confirmed that the homeowners had been clients of the company and said it had previously taken them to the Building Disputes Tribunal for mediation over unpaid money. That case was unsuccessful.

The builder was not charged. Asked why, Auckland Council said all enforcement options had been considered when charging decisions were made. It added that it acknowledges the court’s finding that the defendants were misled by the building company, but that the reasons the company was not prosecuted are subject to legal professional privilege.

Paul Cowling, the council’s team leader for investigations, said no legal action against the builder is now planned. He said the decision recorded in the file was that prosecution did not meet the public interest test.

He said: “The circumstances surrounding the building work were not straightforward. The veranda was constructed by a subcontractor engaged by the building company, while the work on the extension was completed by another individual who has not been identified.”

He added that the work was completed more than 12 months ago, so the council “is therefore no longer able to pursue prosecution in relation to that work.”

Lessons For Homeowners Who Hire A Builder

The case is a warning that in New Zealand the owner can be the one prosecuted when a builder skips consents, even when the owner hired a professional to handle the renovation. It also shows a court weighing who actually knew the rules and how a conviction could affect a person’s career.

Homeowners anywhere can borrow a few sensible habits from it:

  • Ask your builder in writing who is responsible for obtaining permits or consents, and ask to see them before work starts.
  • Check with your local council that approvals are in place, especially for additions such as verandas, decks and backyard buildings.
  • Keep contracts, emails and invoices, since records helped show who was relying on whom.
  • Be wary of any contractor who says a permit is not needed without pointing you to the rule.

For this Ponsonby couple, the outcome was a discharge without conviction and a bill for costs. For the council, it was a finding that the people who hired a professional were the ones misled.

More Stories You May Like

  • Couple Who Bought A Building For A Wedding Venue Find Two 15 Foot Pocket Doors Over 100 Years Old Hidden Behind A Wall After A Local Tipped Them Off
  • Couple Fixes A Dangerously Wobbly Deck Railing With 24 Lag Bolts And 11 Brackets, Then Finds Out They Are Already Out Of Washers After Buying 20
  • Builder Reveals 5 Upgrades That Actually Pay You Back In Equity, And The First One Isn’t In The House At All, It’s The Dirt, Where Power Lines Over The Lot Hurt Value
←Previous

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search

Categories

  • DIY & Repair
  • Feast & Festivity
  • Gather & Grow
  • Home & Harmony
  • Home Improvement & Renovation
  • Home Maintenance & Seasonal Prep
  • Home Safety & Recalls
  • Money-Saving Home Hacks
  • Style & Sanctuary
  • Tools & Gear
  • Trending
  • Uncategorized

Archives

  • November 2026
  • October 2026
  • September 2026
  • August 2026
  • July 2026
  • June 2026
  • May 2026
  • April 2026
  • March 2026
  • February 2026
  • January 2026
  • December 2025
  • November 2025
  • October 2025
  • July 2025
  • June 2025
  • March 2025

Latest Post

  • Couple Prosecuted Over A Veranda And A Backyard Building Added Without Permits Walks Away Without A Conviction After A Judge Finds Their Builder Misled Them
  • Homeowner Puts Up Signs Saying ‘Your GPS Is Wrong Turn Around,’ But Drivers Using Uber Keep Tearing Across His Front Lawn To Avoid Cars Parked In His Driveway
  • State Farm Agrees To Pay More Than $45 Million After Independent Engineers Inspected Oklahoma Roofs It Denied, And Homeowners Will Get A Notice By Dec. 31 On How To Opt In

Willow and Hearth

Willow and Hearth is your trusted companion for creating a beautiful, welcoming home and garden. From inspired seasonal décor and elegant DIY projects to timeless gardening tips and comforting home recipes, our content blends style, practicality, and warmth. Whether you’re curating a cozy living space or nurturing a blooming backyard, we’re here to help you make every corner feel like home.

Contact us at:
[email protected]

    • About
    • Blog
    • Contact Us
    • Editorial Policy
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions

© 2025 Willow and Hearth