Ah, the holiday season. A time for joy, laughter, and… family negotiations? If you’re anything like me, the thought of splitting holidays with in-laws sends a shiver down your spine. It’s not that I don’t love them; it’s just that every year feels like a delicate balancing act — one that often leaves me feeling a little off-kilter. It’s a classic case of “what’s fair” versus “what’s actually fair,” and let me tell you, they’re not always the same thing.
The Great Holiday Tug-of-War
Picture this: It’s December, and you’re getting ready for the holidays. Your calendar is filling up faster than a kid’s plate at a Thanksgiving buffet. Your in-laws want to see you on Christmas Eve, but your own family’s been doing a big dinner on that same night for decades. So, what do you do? You find yourself in a tug-of-war, trying to keep everyone happy while you secretly wish for a holiday that involves nothing more than cozy pajamas, hot cocoa, and a good book.
It sounds simple, right? Just split the holidays evenly. But here’s the kicker: “Evenly” can mean so many different things. Maybe your in-laws expect you to spend Christmas with them every other year, while your family thinks you should alternate every holiday. And what about those pesky little traditions that everyone holds dear? They may feel like small potatoes, but when you’re trying to appease both sides, every mashed potato counts.
Why It Never Feels Equal
So why does it never feel equal? Well, for starters, there’s the emotional weight of family history. Maybe your in-laws have a long-standing tradition of Christmas caroling that they can’t let go of, while your family has their own set of rituals that are equally cherished. It’s hard to measure that in calendar days. And let’s be real — some families can make a mean turkey, while others play a mean game of “who can be the loudest during dinner.”
Then there’s the travel factor. Some families live just a hop, skip, and jump away, while others require a trek across several states. If you’re spending hours in the car or on a plane just to get to your in-laws’ house, the time spent with them might feel disproportionately larger. Suddenly, they’re getting the lion’s share of your holiday time, and it’s tough to swallow.
Setting Boundaries: A Friendly Approach
Now, I’m all about family harmony, but I’m also a firm believer in setting boundaries. It’s essential to communicate your needs clearly and lovingly. Instead of a stern “We can’t do that,” try something like, “We’d love to spend Christmas Eve with you, but we also need to see my family that night. How about we make it work next year?” This way, you’re not just shutting down their hopes; you’re opening the door for compromise.
And speaking of compromise, why not mix things up? Suggest hosting a holiday gathering that includes both sides of the family. Just imagine the chaos! You could have your in-laws singing carols in one room while your own family is arguing over the best way to carve a ham in another. It might just be the most memorable holiday yet — and who doesn’t love a little family drama? Just remember to keep the eggnog flowing!
Finding Your Own Holiday Joy
In the end, the holidays should be about joy, not stress. It’s easy to get caught up in the demands and expectations of family, but don’t forget to carve out some time for yourself. Whether that means taking a quiet morning to sip coffee and reflect or planning a little getaway with just your immediate family, prioritize what truly brings you happiness.
And hey, if that means skipping out on one family gathering to ensure you don’t lose your sanity, so be it! It’s not selfish; it’s self-care. Trust me, a calm and happy you will make for a much better holiday experience all around.
The Takeaway
At the end of the day, splitting holidays with in-laws doesn’t have to feel like a game of tug-of-war. It’s all about communication, compromise, and a sprinkle of creativity. Remember, it’s perfectly okay to advocate for your needs while also honoring your family’s traditions. So grab that hot cocoa, put your feet up, and get ready to navigate the holiday season with grace — and maybe a little humor
More from Willow and Hearth:

Leave a Reply