If you rent in Philadelphia, the rules about being told to leave have just changed. Landlords must now give a written reason before they end or decline to renew any lease, no matter how long that lease runs.

The change is part of the Safe Healthy Homes Act, a package of city laws developed with tenant organizers. WHYY’s PlanPhilly team laid out what the new renter protection laws do, and the fight around them has been anything but quiet.
Supporters say the laws will protect renters who speak up. Independent landlords say they will hurt small businesses.
A Written Reason Is Now Required For Every Lease, Not Just Short Ones
The first piece expands “good cause” protections to all renters in Philadelphia. Regardless of the term of a tenant’s lease, landlords must state in writing the legitimate, legally defined reason they want to end or not renew it.
Until now, that rule applied only to month-to-month leases and leases running less than a year. Advocates say that left a loophole, because a landlord could effectively push out a tenant with a longer lease without justifying the decision or even giving advance notice.
Legal experts say that made it hard for renters to dispute a move they suspected was payback and to file a complaint with the city. “It’s not necessarily a hard and fast rule, but it makes it really hard to challenge it when you’re kind of fighting against silence,” said Madison Gray, a staff attorney with the Public Interest Law Center, in February.
Speaking To A Reporter Or Joining A Tenants Group Can No Longer Cost You Your Lease
The second piece bars landlords from ending or changing a lease simply because a tenant is cooperating with a city investigation, has talked about living conditions with a council member or reporter, or has joined a tenants association.
Backers like this part especially. Tenants always had the right to organize, but the law never spelled it out. Advocates say the change should help more renters form associations to protect their rights.
“We’re not asking for luxury. We’re asking that if we get a leak in our kitchen, you come fix it,” said Theresa Howell, an organizer with OnePA Renters United, in September.
Tenants Can Sue For Back Rent Collected Illegally
The third piece clarifies that tenants have the right to sue for back rent if a landlord illegally collected payment. Under city law, landlords must have an active rental license and a certificate of rental suitability to collect rent.
There is a safety valve for landlords. They will not be penalized if they lack those documents because of administrative delays from the city, including at the Department of Licenses and Inspections.
The package was crafted by Councilmember Nicolas O’Rourke, who introduced it. “These laws will not create a sea change overnight,” he said in a statement. He added that he believes the city will see safer housing, better landlord business practices and stronger protection from retaliation or displacement if the laws are faithfully carried out.
“I Could End Up In Foreclosure,” Warns An Independent Landlord
Opponents say the legislation could still do damage. They suspect it will be harder, and likely more costly, to remove problem tenants, and that landlords might have to hand out rent rebates they cannot afford.
“I could run into the wrong tenant with this legislation, not be able to make my mortgage on my properties and end up in foreclosure,” said Seth Floyd, an independent landlord.
It is a fear many small owners will recognize. A single tenant who stops paying can strain a landlord with a mortgage on the same property.
A Last-Minute Lawsuit Sent The Bills Back To Committee
City Council passed the measures in April after a long process that pitted fair housing advocates against independent landlords. Mayor Cherelle Parker signed them into law less than two months later.
Lawmakers had been expected to approve them in March, but a day before the vote, two landlords sued Council’s housing committee, alleging it violated state and federal law. A settlement reached the same day sent the bills back to committee, and members had to retrace their steps before the final vote. The committee then held three public hearings.
That lawsuit remains open, and a federal judge was set to hear the city’s motion to dismiss it.
Lawmakers earlier passed another part of the package, a measure authorizing an anti-displacement fund for tenants forced out because their home became uninhabitable. After pushback from the Parker administration, O’Rourke agreed to hold the remaining bills for more negotiations and amendments. The fund is now part of Parker’s signature housing initiative, though it is not yet operational.
What Renters And Landlords Should Do Now
Whichever side of the lease you sit on, the new rules reward good records. These are general tips, not legal advice.
- Tenants: keep every notice, text and email about your lease, and ask for any termination or non-renewal reason in writing.
- Tenants: if you are organizing neighbors or speaking to officials about conditions, the new law says that alone cannot be the reason your lease ends.
- Landlords: confirm you hold an active rental license and a certificate of rental suitability before collecting rent.
- Landlords: if the city is slow to issue those documents, keep proof of your application, since administrative delays are not penalized.
- Everyone: check with the city or a housing counselor for how the rules apply to a specific lease.
Supporters hope the laws will let renters report dangerous conditions without fear. Opponents worry about costs they cannot absorb. Both sides are watching the court case that could still shape how it all plays out.
More Stories You May Like
- Virginia Landlords Must Now Give Renters 14 Days Instead Of 5 On A Pay Or Quit Notice And Must Accept Checks And Money Orders For Rent
- 10 Things Landlords Generally Cannot Do To A Tenant, From Changing The Locks To Shutting Off The Utilities, And Why State Law Decides The Details
- Before Paying To Apply For An Apartment, Check These 8 Rental Application Fee Rules, Including The States That Cap What Landlords Can Charge
Leave a Reply