Most people picture a garden pond as a calm corner of the yard. For a 92-year-old woman in a tiny French village, it turned into a matter for the police, all because of three frogs that moved in on their own.

Colette Ferry of Frontenex got a visit from local law enforcement after neighbors complained about the noise from the frogs in her yard.
The Frogs Are Not Even Her Pets
Here is the part that makes the story so odd. The three frogs in question are not Ferry’s pets, so she has little control over them. They simply showed up and made the pond home.
Frontenex is a village in the Savoie region of the northern Alps with a population of around 1,800. Two gendarmes visited her home and told her they would remove the three frogs.
The dispute has been called a “culture war,” the latest example of a conflict of rights between town and country, nature and neighbor.
She Says The Frogs Play With Her Fish, And She Calls Them Her Entertainment
Ferry spoke to a local radio station, and her words have been quoted ever since. “They’re in and out of the water playing with my fish. It’s my entertainment,” she said.
She also described the visit from a neighbor. “A man came here and was really yelling at me, saying he could not sleep and he had to work … but I did not expect the police. Especially not for frogs! But there’s always someone ready to complain about someone else.”
Then came her take on the police promise to return. “That’ll be fun … they jump,” she said.
A Petition, A Quiet Life And A Granddaughter’s Worry
There is more backstory. Neighbors found the croaking “incessant” and started a petition, and police were called to her property at the end of April, which gave the neighbors an official record of the noise.
Ferry has lived alone since her husband died 20 years ago. The frogs are her companionship, and she said she had never had a problem with neighbors before.
Her closest neighbor said she is a bit hard of hearing and not necessarily bothered by the croaking. Her granddaughter said the whole episode upset her: “Grandma felt like a delinquent, whereas she had always led her life with exemplary uprightness.”
A Lake For The Frogs, Then A Change Of Heart
Police first proposed moving the frogs to a nearby lake, and Ferry initially accepted the plan. She later withdrew her approval after talking it over with her family.
The story has a countryside echo. French lawmakers passed a law protecting the country’s “sensory heritage,” meaning the sounds and smells of local wildlife.
“Living in the countryside implies accepting some nuisances,” Joël Giraud, who was the minister for rural life when the law passed, told lawmakers.
When Kindness To Nature Meets The Neighbors
Ferry is far from the first homeowner to find that kindness toward nature can put you at odds with the neighbors. Homeowners regularly complain online about strict neighbors and homeowners associations that oppose vegetable gardens that help local ecosystems and compost bins that cut waste.
Noise disputes in France usually start with talking to the person responsible, then going to a conciliateur de justice, a mediator who tries to find an agreement.
If that fails, you can call the police or gendarmerie, who can record the noise in an official note. Fines are typically €68, can rise to €180 if unpaid within 45 days, and can reach €450 for nighttime disturbances.
Frogs call mostly in warm weather, when males sing to attract mates, so a pond can sound like a chorus on spring and summer nights. That is part of nature’s routine, and it is the very thing neighbors in this story could hear.
The lesson from Frontenex is not that anyone is a villain. It is that a little patience on both sides of the fence can keep a small pond from turning into a big dispute.
Lessons For Anyone With A Backyard Pond
A pond is a magnet for wildlife, and frogs are among the first visitors. If you want to enjoy the water without upsetting the neighbors, a friendly word early on can go a long way.
Tell the people next door that you have a pond, and what you are hoping to enjoy. A quick chat over the fence is easier than a visit from the police, and many neighbors turn out to like a little wildlife.
If noise becomes a real issue, try small fixes first. Mediation and a polite conversation often work better than formal complaints.
For Colette Ferry, the frogs are a daily show, with the fish, the water and the jumping. Whatever happens next, her words say it best: it is her entertainment.
More Stories You May Like
- Homeowners Say They Are Being Forced Out After HOA Fees Jumped From $158 To $2,500 A Month In Five Years, And The Board Blames Neighbors Who Sued
- LA Landlords Are Turning Tenants’ Parking Spaces Into New Apartments, And A Judge Halted One Project Converting 20 Spaces Into Nine Units While A 70 Year Old Renter Says Parking Is Her Freedom
- California Brothers Promised Affordable Backyard Homes, Now Face 35 Felony Counts Each After Prosecutors Say They Collected More Than $1 Million From 13 Projects Without Doing The Work
Leave a Reply