If you rent in New York City, you already know the number is bad. Realtor.com’s third-quarter report puts the median asking rent at a record $3,785 a month, up 4.5% from a year ago.

That is the highest figure the company has recorded since it began tracking rents in 2019. And an economist there adds a sobering line for anyone dreaming of a way out by buying: a typical home costs nearly three times as much as renting.
Rents Are $816 Above Where They Were Before The Pandemic
The citywide median asking rent of $3,785 is $816 higher than the pre-pandemic level. That works out to 27.5% more.
Put another way, a household paying the median today is handing over thousands of dollars more each year than it would have in early 2020. For retirees on fixed incomes, those dollars have nowhere to come from.
The numbers cover Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens and the Bronx. Staten Island was not tracked.
Smaller Apartments Are Climbing The Fastest
The report finds that studios through two-bedroom apartments rose 7.1% to a median of $3,662. Larger apartments of three bedrooms or more rose 2.9% to $5,089.
Jiayi Xu, a senior economist at Realtor.com, describes the growth as broad-based, with the sharpest increase in smaller units. That means young singles, couples and retirees who downsize feel it most.
Manhattan Leads With A Jump Of 8.3%
Here is how the boroughs look. Manhattan rose 8.3% to $5,375, the largest increase in the city.
Brooklyn climbed 4.9% to $4,197, while Queens rose 3.9% to $3,774. The Bronx rose 2.7% to $3,233.
Even the cheapest borough on the list now has a median rent above what many families pay on a mortgage in other parts of the country. That is the sort of statistic that makes people rethink where they want to live.
Buying Costs Nearly Three Times As Much As Renting
Xu notes that buying a typical home in the city costs nearly three times as much as renting. That is a big gap, and it explains why so many people keep renting even as rents rise.
Mortgage rates are part of the story. The average 30-year fixed rate rose above 7% in September, and Danielle Hale, the company’s chief economist, says rates above 7% can quickly erase any relief in home prices.
She sums up the situation this way: “New York City renters are facing a difficult affordability equation.”
The Federal Reserve is also expected to raise interest rates again at its December meeting, and ten-year Treasury yields are hovering near multi-year highs, which keeps borrowing costs elevated.
Why Owning Is Not The Escape Hatch It Used To Be
For many renters, the dream is to stop paying a landlord and start building equity. The numbers make that harder.
A buyer faces the down payment, closing costs, taxes, insurance and repairs, along with a much higher monthly bill. If you cannot afford both a bigger payment and a cushion for the unexpected, staying put may be the wiser choice.
Renting has a hidden advantage, too. When the boiler fails or the roof leaks, it is the landlord’s problem, and you are not stuck with a bill the size of a car.
How To Keep Your Rent From Eating You Alive
Whether you live in New York or anywhere else, the same sound habits apply. Start by knowing your rights. In New York, many apartments are covered by rent stabilization rules, and tenants can ask the state housing agency whether their unit is stabilized.
When your lease comes up for renewal, do not simply accept the first number. Ask your landlord whether there is room to negotiate, especially if you pay on time and keep the place in good order. A long-term, reliable tenant is worth something.
Consider a longer lease to lock in a rate, and ask what the increase would be for one year versus two. Compare the cost of moving, including a broker’s fee, movers and a security deposit, against the increase.
Look at roommates, or a smaller place a short train ride away. A slightly longer commute can save hundreds of dollars a month, and the outer boroughs often offer more space for the money.
Check your budget against a simple rule of thumb. Many financial planners suggest keeping rent to about 30% of your gross income, and many New Yorkers are far above that. If you are, look for ways to trim other costs.
If You Are Thinking Of Buying Instead
Run your own numbers before you decide. Use a mortgage calculator to see what the monthly payment would be at today’s rate, then add taxes, insurance and maintenance.
Ask a lender about first-time buyer programs, which can lower the down payment, and talk to a housing counselor approved by the federal housing agency. Many counselors work for free or a low fee.
Build a cushion before you buy. A good target is several months of expenses set aside after the down payment, so one surprise does not become a crisis.
You can find more market data on Realtor.com’s research pages.
More Stories You May Like
- Landlord Cannot Change The Locks When A Tenant Stops Paying Rent, Lawyer Says, And A Nonpayment Eviction Still Needs 14 Days Notice And A Trip To Court
- Gardener Of 20 Years Has Not Fertilized Her Border In Years, Waters A Handful Of Times In Summer, And Says Number One Plant Survives Being Thrown From A Car Window
- Before You Close On A Home, Check These 12 Costs On Your Closing Disclosure
Leave a Reply