Willow and Hearth

  • Grow
  • Home
  • Style
  • Feast
CONTACT US
A dirt road running through a forest
Home & Harmony

Neighbors Sue After A Company Cuts About 250 Trees From A Forest Meant To Shield Their Homes From Buried Coal Ash, And A Federal Jury Is Now Deciding Whether It Owes $3.3 Million

A forest is not supposed to be the center of a federal trial, but in Cincinnati this month it is. A group of neighbors says a company cut about 250 trees from a strip of woods that was promised to them nearly four decades ago, and a federal jury is now deciding whether the company owes $3.3 million.

A dirt road running through a forest

The group is called Neighbors Opposed to Pit Expansion, or NOPE, and its members are residents of Pierce Township, Ohio. They filed the lawsuit back in 2019, and the jury trial opened on Nov. 9 in U.S. District Court. It is expected to run about a week, according to trial reporting from WCPO 9 I-Team.

The land sits next to the former William C. Beckjord coal plant on the Ohio River, about 20 miles east of Cincinnati. The plant was built in the 1950s, and Duke Energy closed it in 2014.

“We Wanted It To Be Left Alone,” Neighbors Tell The Jury About Their 1986 Deal

To understand the fight, you have to go back to 1985. Christopher Knoop, a former Pierce Township trustee and member of the NOPE steering committee, was the first witness. He told jurors the group formed that year when Cincinnati Gas & Electric began buying up properties to expand its coal ash pits.

Both the township and the residents threatened to sue. Instead, they reached a 1986 agreement that included keeping a greenbelt of trees around the site. “We agreed virtually from the beginning … to not disturb this property,” Knoop said.

NOPE attorney Dave Altman put it plainly in his opening statement. “We wanted it to be left alone,” he told the jury.

According to NOPE, that 1986 agreement required the company to keep the buffer in a “substantially undisturbed” state. The agreement also required disclosure of how contaminated waste was disposed of on the property.

Roughly 250 Walnut, Maple, Cherry And Pine Trees Came Down In 2019

The current owner is Missouri-based Commercial Liability Partners, known as CLP, which bought the 1,443-acre site from Duke Energy in February 2018. CLP owns the greenbelt land, but NOPE holds the easement that protects it.

In 2019, the neighbors say, CLP cut roughly 250 walnut, maple, cherry and pine trees, some of them about 50 feet tall. The company also cut logging roads through the forest.

Allen Freeman, chairman of the Pierce Township Board of Trustees, said the damage was easy to spot from the site. He described “the backs of trees that were just cut straight down.”

The neighbors are asking for $3.3 million. This first trial covers only the greenbelt. A separate jury will hear the other claims at a later trial.

The Company Says The Words “Mature Forest” Are Nowhere In The Agreement

CLP sees it differently. Its attorney, Gregory DeGulis, told jurors that “Substantially undisturbed state is the main term we’re arguing about.”

He pointed out that the phrases “mature forest” and “trees” do not appear in the settlement agreement. In other words, the fight comes down to what two simple words, “substantially undisturbed,” actually mean in a legal document written in 1986.

NOPE expects neighbors to testify about what they lost, including tree canopy, small flowers, the forest floor and wildlife habitat. Wild turkeys are on the list, and so is the spread of invasive honeysuckle.

Freeman explained why the trees matter beyond looks. The buffer protects the hillsides and the ash pits, he said, adding, “That buffer is not just the trees above but the root system below.”

Why Neighbors Care So Much About What Sits Behind The Trees

The woods are not just a pretty view. More than 5 million tons of coal ash are buried in unlined, man-made ponds along the Ohio River at the site.

The river is a drinking water source for more than 5 million people in Greater Cincinnati and Northern Kentucky. The ponds sit about 1,000 feet from Clermont County’s primary drinking water wells, which serve 145,000 residents.

The trial is not the only legal action. NOPE also alleges that CLP failed to disclose how it dug up and moved coal ash, and that it used an underfunded corporate shell, New Richmond Development Corp., to shield itself from liability. Those claims wait for the later trial.

On Sept. 24, Clermont County sued CLP, Duke Energy and another owner to force a coal ash cleanup before it contaminates the drinking water supply. In May 2026, the Ohio EPA inspected the site, found significant noncompliance over violations at two ash ponds, and issued a notice of violation in June.

Freeman has not been shy about his frustration. “Quite frankly, it’s been a disappointment every step of the way,” he said in June. Of the two lawsuits, he said, “We have an opportunity right now utilizing these two lawsuits to really get a do-over.”

What Every Homeowner Near A Protected Buffer Should Take From This

You do not have to live near a coal plant to learn something from this case. Plenty of homeowners count on a green buffer, a drainage easement or a restriction that was put in place decades ago.

A few habits can protect you if your own neighborhood has one:

  • Find the paperwork. Easements and agreements are usually recorded with your county recorder, and a title company can help you locate them.
  • Read the exact wording. As this trial shows, a phrase like “substantially undisturbed” can be argued over for years.
  • Note who holds the easement. In this case the company owns the land, but the neighbors’ group controls the easement.
  • Take dated photos of any shared green space so you can show what it looked like before changes.
  • Go to township and council meetings. Trustees like Freeman can only act on what they hear about.

The jury’s answer will decide whether a promise made in 1986 still has teeth in 2026. Until it comes in, the neighbors of Pierce Township are waiting to learn what a forest is worth.

More Stories You May Like

  • Federal Regulators Say Stop Using Certain Amazon Gate Opener Remotes Because Children Can Access Their Coin Batteries, And The Seller Has Not Issued A Recall
  • Pennsylvania Households Can Get Up To $1,000 In Heating Help Through April 23, 2027, And Utilities Cannot Shut Off Electric Or Gas From December 1 For Eligible Homes
  • Waiting Until The Soil Is So Cold Seed Can’t Sprout Is The Cheapest Way To Fix Bare Lawn Spots, And Skipping One Sprinkler Step Cracks Buried Pipes By Spring
←Previous
Next→

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search

Categories

  • DIY & Repair
  • Feast & Festivity
  • Gather & Grow
  • Home & Harmony
  • Home Improvement & Renovation
  • Home Maintenance & Seasonal Prep
  • Home Safety & Recalls
  • Money-Saving Home Hacks
  • Style & Sanctuary
  • Tools & Gear
  • Trending
  • Uncategorized

Archives

  • November 2026
  • October 2026
  • September 2026
  • August 2026
  • July 2026
  • June 2026
  • May 2026
  • April 2026
  • March 2026
  • February 2026
  • January 2026
  • December 2025
  • November 2025
  • October 2025
  • July 2025
  • June 2025
  • March 2025

Latest Post

  • Plumbers Say A Water Heater Never Drained In 10 Years Should Probably Not Be Drained Now, Because Stirring Up The Sediment Can Cause Leaks And Valve Failure
  • Woman Buys A Second $300 Skeleton Horse For Her Christmas Yard, Then A Neighbor’s Letter Calls It Halloween Junk And Ends With My Name Is Not Karen, So She Fires Back You Just Earned That Name
  • Woman Rents A Town Home In A 60 Home Gated Golf Community Next To Her Best Friend, Then Finds A Filthy House, Pays A Cleaner $150 For Three Days, And The Landlord Reimburses $100

Willow and Hearth

Willow and Hearth is your trusted companion for creating a beautiful, welcoming home and garden. From inspired seasonal décor and elegant DIY projects to timeless gardening tips and comforting home recipes, our content blends style, practicality, and warmth. Whether you’re curating a cozy living space or nurturing a blooming backyard, we’re here to help you make every corner feel like home.

Contact us at:
[email protected]

    • About
    • Blog
    • Contact Us
    • Editorial Policy
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions

© 2025 Willow and Hearth