Mary Murray and Jeffrey Ment had a problem many big families know well. They have six children, they needed room for eight people, and the house they wanted had two bedrooms.

They bought it anyway in 2020 for $1.45 million, at 151 Polpis Road on Nantucket. According to reporting from the Nantucket Current, they did it because their agent told them the home could be doubled in size.
A Norfolk Superior Court jury and Judge Ira Gant later found that agent, Melanie Gowen of William Raveis Nantucket, misled them. The house could not be expanded.
“We Never Questioned Melanie Because She Said She’d Gone To The Building Department”
The expansion was blocked by a deed restriction and by zoning rules. Murray says the couple never double checked the claim because of what Gowen told them about her homework.
“We never questioned Melanie because she said she’d gone to the building department,” Murray said.
The couple filed their lawsuit in 2021. Murray says they never wanted to sue and first tried to reach an amicable deal with William Raveis, but that effort failed. She says Gowen told them there was nothing more she could do, and that the company told them to sue.
The Jury Said Yes, And The Judgment Hit $1,280,886 Plus Interest
The jury verdict came in January 2026, and an amended judgment followed in June 2026. The total is $1,280,886, and it continues to grow with interest.
The jury assigned 65% of the damages to Gowen’s negligence and 35% to the buyers’ own negligence. Just over $867,000 of the total is doubled damages, with the rest covering other costs, including attorneys’ fees and interest.
In plain terms, the jury found the agent misled the couple, but it also decided the couple carried part of the blame.
“Realtors Should Read This,” Says The Buyer, While The Firm Says It Will Win On Appeal
William Raveis and Gowen filed a notice of appeal in October 2026, and they strongly disagree with the outcome. Their attorney, Ray Chasen, says the buyers received the document restricting expansion 11 days before closing and that two lawyers reviewed it.
Chasen also says the home’s septic restrictions limited it to two bedrooms. He says the buyers asked the sellers to waive the septic restriction, the sellers refused, and the buyers bought the house anyway.
He points to testimony that Ment does not believe Gowen lied to him, and says there was no actionable misrepresentation. He says the firm expects the Appeals Court to agree. The defendants denied wrongdoing and argued they breached no duty and cannot be held liable over facts outside their knowledge.
A spokesperson for the firm, named as Cashman, said the company has built its reputation over more than 50 years and takes pride in its business conduct and client trust.
Murray has a message for the industry. She rejects any suggestion that the case is frivolous, describing herself and Ment as busy professionals who care for others. “Realtors should read this and say, if I’m taking shortcuts, I shouldn’t do that anymore.”
What Happened To The Family After The Sale
Property records show the couple sold 151 Polpis Road in 2021 for $1.95 million. The newspaper called that a gross profit of about half a million dollars.
Murray says the real number was much smaller. After Land Bank fees, improvements and mortgage payments, she says their actual profit was closer to $125,000.
They later bought a home on Gardener Road for more than $3 million, well above their original budget. Murray says that when they started searching again in 2021, nothing was available under $1 million and everything was at least $2 million. “I don’t feel good about the debt we have,” she said.
How To Protect Yourself Before You Pay For A House You Plan To Expand
This case is still in the appeals process, so the final word has not been written. But the story carries a lesson for anyone buying a home with plans to add on.
- Get every promise in writing. If an agent says a house can be doubled, ask for the source of that statement in an email.
- Call the building department yourself. Ask whether your exact plan would be approved for that exact address.
- Read the deed and every recorded restriction. Ask your attorney to explain anything that limits additions.
- Ask about septic or sewer limits. In this case, septic restrictions are central to what the home could hold.
- Do not rely on a single person. Even with two lawyers reviewing documents, this couple ended up in court.
- Build in time. The firm says the restriction document arrived 11 days before closing. Ask for papers as early as possible.
For a family of eight, the stakes were never abstract. A home that could grow was the whole reason for the purchase, and the price tag of $1.45 million made it the biggest financial decision of their lives.
The buyers say they trusted what they were told. The firm says they had every document they needed. A court of appeals will now weigh in on which of those stories carries the day.
More Stories You May Like
- Beautiful New Texas Home Passes The Eye Test, Then The Warranty Inspection Finds Step Cracks, Missing Soffit Vents And Cracking AC Line Insulation
- Inspector Walks Through A Brand New Home And Finds Two Showers That Are Not Watertight, Loose Window Trim And Debris Already In The Drain
- Inspector Checks A $1.7M New Construction Home And Finds A Shower That Is Not Watertight Plus A Condensate Line Run Where It Blocks HVAC Service
Leave a Reply