Britney Ellerby and her husband did what millions of first-time buyers dream of doing. In 2025 they bought their first home on South Dunlop Street in Petersburg and settled in. Then a letter from a lawyer arrived and the backyard they had been calling their own turned out to belong to someone else.

Now the couple is speaking out so the next family does not get caught the same way. Their message is simple: get a property survey before you buy, no matter how nice the yard looks.
Original report: 12 On Your Side.
The Seller Put Down Gravel To Mark What They Believed Was The Backyard
When the Ellerbys bought the house, the seller had laid gravel behind it to outline what the seller believed was the backyard. That gravel was the only boundary the family had to go on. Over the following year they fenced the space in and shaped it around their two children.
A Letter From The Neighbor’s Attorneys Said The Fence Had To Come Down
After about a year, the family was told the fence they had put up needed to come down. The yard the parents had customized for their kids needed to be cleared. The notice came in a letter from the attorneys of the new owner of a home on nearby Willox Street.
That letter explained that a property survey found the Ellerbys’ backyard does not belong to them. Listing photos for the Willox Street home show the Ellerbys’ fenced-in yard as it looked at the time the house was listed, which makes the surprise even sharper.
The couple did not simply take the neighbor’s word for it. They had their own survey done, and it confirmed the same thing: they do not have a backyard.
“We Would Have Nothing” Once The Property Line Reaches The Alley
Ellerby says she is disappointed but not surprised by what the survey showed. According to their unrecorded survey, the line runs all the way to the alley, which would cut the family off from the space behind their own house.
She says they were told they are trespassing. “Wow. We would have nothing,” she said.
Her request is a modest one. “We are asking for a time period to remove our things in dignity so that we can figure out exactly where we need to move them to,” she said.
Why The Porch Is Part Of The Problem Too
A real estate expert who walked the property with the reporter pointed to the family’s porch. The distance from the edge of the house to the edge of the porch is roughly 8 feet. With a typical setback of about 5 feet, he explained, a porch of that size would sit right on the property line.
That is exactly why counties require permits for work like this. A permit office would ask to see a survey and ask how close the structure sits to the line. The expert said he is willing to bet there was no permit for the porch, because the county would have stopped the project before it started.
The Ellerbys say that as first-time buyers they were never educated about property surveys, and there was not one on file for the Dunlop Street house.
Why A Survey May Not Be Sitting In A File Somewhere
The expert said that is not unusual. A survey often will not be on file, and sellers frequently do not want to hand theirs over. If you are selling a house, he noted, the buyer can always get their own.
When a survey is old, a title company will often want a fresh one. Buyers who use a mortgage will usually run into that requirement through the lender and the title company.
Surveys also cost money, and that is the main reason many buyers skip them. Still, the Ellerbys’ story shows what can be at stake when a buyer goes without one: part of the lot they thought they owned.
What Every Buyer Should Take From This Story
The expert’s advice was blunt. In real estate, never go by “we believe” or “they said.” He gave examples of the kind of stories sellers tell: a lawyer once said so, a grandpa put a fence post down years ago, there has always been a fence there so it must be ours.
“Never go by that,” he said. “If it is not in writing, it does not count.” His rule for buyers is to never purchase a house without a survey unless you are a true expert.
Here is a practical checklist for anyone shopping for a home:
- Order a boundary survey from a licensed surveyor before closing, and ask for the marked corners to be shown to you.
- Do not treat a fence, a row of gravel or a line of shrubs as proof of where the lot ends.
- Ask whether decks, porches and sheds on the property were permitted, since a permit usually means someone checked the setbacks.
- Get every promise from the seller in writing, including anything said about the yard.
For the Ellerbys, those lessons come a year too late. They bought their first home, built a backyard for their children, and now face moving their things out of it. They are sharing the story so that other families get a survey done instead of learning the hard way.
More Stories You May Like
- Couple Buys Their First Home After Multiple Inspections Found Nothing, Then Finds At Least 25 Snakes Inside, And A Neighbor Says The Snakes Were Free With Purchase
- New York Couple Moves Into A Brand New Apartment, Then A Mystery Tapping Behind The Bathroom Wall Gets So Loud Engineers Bust Open The Shower And Find A Pipe Expanding
- HOA Agrees To Pay $200,000 After Denying A Couple’s Backyard Fence For Their Children With Special Needs, Then Each Homeowner Is Told To Pay $1,350 And 55 Neighbors Still Have Not, So The Couple Sues Again
Leave a Reply