Willow and Hearth

  • Grow
  • Home
  • Style
  • Feast
CONTACT US
A wooden backyard fence with palm trees in the background
Home & Harmony

HOA Agrees To Pay $200,000 After Denying A Couple’s Backyard Fence For Their Children With Special Needs, Then Each Homeowner Is Told To Pay $1,350 And 55 Neighbors Still Have Not, So The Couple Sues Again

A backyard fence went up in a De Pere, Wisconsin subdivision, and the bill for the fight over it is still landing on doorsteps. A homeowners association agreed to pay a couple $200,000, each homeowner was told to pay $1,350, and now 55 neighbors are said to still owe their share.

A wooden backyard fence with palm trees in the background

The couple, Lisa and Michael Newman, have filed a second lawsuit this fall. The latest chapter was reported by NBC 26 Green Bay, whose reporter went door to door in the Nazcr Trac subdivision.

It is a cautionary tale about what happens when a board says no, and about who ends up paying when that no turns out to be wrong.

“No Fences Of Any Kind” Collided With A Family’s Medical Needs

Lisa and Michael Newman live in Nazcr Trac with their five children. Lisa Newman said all five have been diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder and also have physical medical complexities.

She said she wanted them to be able to play outside without running away and getting lost, and the children’s doctors and caregivers decided a backyard fence was needed. She described the family’s life as “constantly shifting kids from one place to another for their therapy, doctor’s appointments.”

In 2019 the family asked the Nazcr Trac Property Owner’s Association board for special permission to build one. The board said no, citing a restrictive covenant from the subdivision’s 2001 plat map stating “No fences of any kind shall be allowed.”

“They Just Wanted To Fight Us On It,” Says The Mother

Board minutes from April 2021 point to past fence denials as the reasoning. The minutes say the board was “well aware of when they purchased the property as well as other requests which were not granted, and have decided as a group to deny Mr. Newman’s request for the fence.”

Newman saw it differently. “They just wanted to fight us on it,” she said.

Disability Rights Wisconsin advised the family to get a lawyer, and they filed a complaint in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Wisconsin in 2021. In 2022, under the federal Fair Housing Act, a judge granted the Newmans a preliminary injunction and the fence went up. Newman called that “very exciting.”

The Settlement Came To $200,000, Paid By Association Members

In August 2024 the case settled, with the association agreeing to pay the Newmans $200,000. The money was to come from all association members, at $1,350 for each.

Former board president Kevin Burt was named in the suit along with the association. He was first required to pay $10,000 in a settlement draft, but in September 2024 U.S. District Judge William Griesbach dismissed him as a defendant. Court records show Burt paid the Newmans $1,350.

Burt and another board member, Brad Fisher, planned to resign in 2024, according to May 2024 meeting minutes. Burt declined to comment to the station.

Letters Warned Owners To Pay Or Risk Becoming Defendants

In early 2025, letters went out telling owners to pay “to avoid becoming defendants in a new legal action.” A January 2025 report said 56 homeowners had paid $1,350 since late October, with one paying $2,700 because they own two lots, and nearly 40 homes had not paid.

Neighbors told the station then that the issue divided the neighborhood and that most people had no problem with the fence. One said: “If the board had polled us as members, a large amount of the members would have said, ‘Absolutely, let the family do what they need to do to take care of their family.’”

Another said that when the fence went up, “Most people didn’t even realize that there was a fence there. It’s very unassuming.” Several declined to appear on camera for fear of further legal action.

Now 55 Homeowners Face A Second Lawsuit

According to the current report, sixty-nine homeowners settled after the original lawsuit. The Newmans’ attorney, Victoria Davis Davila, says 55 homeowners still owe money.

This fall the Newmans filed another suit naming the homeowners association and those who still have not paid as defendants. Davis Davila said: “There’s an outstanding judgment. You had the opportunity to pay. You chose not to pay it.”

She added that “The Newmans want just as bad as anybody else to put this behind them.” If the outstanding amount stays unpaid, she said, the HOA membership as a whole could potentially be held liable.

“Why Is This Coming Back To Us?” Neighbors Ask

Residents described the renewed fight as frustrating and stressful, and some called it “deja vu.” One anonymous homeowner said: “Why is this coming back to us? It’s so unfair.”

Another, who remembers thinking “I did nothing wrong. Why should I pay?”, paid to settle after seeking legal advice. Some residents said they did not learn about the original dispute until the settlement was announced.

One said: “We as homeowners had zero input on this, zero involvement at all.” A homeowner who already paid said the possibility of the whole membership being liable “doesn’t go over too well” and that the uncertainty has made him consider moving.

All the neighbors quoted were anonymous, and former board members contacted by the station declined to comment. Neighbors say the HOA is seeking legal representation to respond, and a response to the new litigation was due the week of the report.

What Homeowners Can Learn From The Nazcr Trac Fight

The first lesson is that members can end up paying for decisions they had no part in. If you live in an HOA, attend meetings, read the minutes and ask how legal costs would be funded before a dispute escalates.

The second is that a Fair Housing Act case over a disability accommodation can reach far beyond the board that denied the request. Boards that receive a request tied to a disability would be wise to talk to an attorney before saying no.

The third is that a letter demanding payment deserves a prompt, careful response. Several neighbors here paid after getting legal advice, which is a sensible step if a notice lands in your mailbox.

More Stories You May Like

  • Raleigh Homeowner Who Paid $1,900 For Off-Duty Officers Was Told His Halloween House Needs A Special Event Permit And Says My House Is Not A Special Event
  • Couple Fixes A Dangerously Wobbly Deck Railing With 24 Lag Bolts And 11 Brackets, Then Finds Out They Are Already Out Of Washers After Buying 20
  • Homeowner With About 60,000 Synchronized Christmas Lights Is Fined $100 And Sues His HOA After It Rejected His Offer To Run At 30% Brightness
←Previous

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search

Categories

  • DIY & Repair
  • Feast & Festivity
  • Gather & Grow
  • Home & Harmony
  • Home Improvement & Renovation
  • Home Maintenance & Seasonal Prep
  • Home Safety & Recalls
  • Money-Saving Home Hacks
  • Style & Sanctuary
  • Tools & Gear
  • Trending
  • Uncategorized

Archives

  • November 2026
  • October 2026
  • September 2026
  • August 2026
  • July 2026
  • June 2026
  • May 2026
  • April 2026
  • March 2026
  • February 2026
  • January 2026
  • December 2025
  • November 2025
  • October 2025
  • July 2025
  • June 2025
  • March 2025

Latest Post

  • HOA Agrees To Pay $200,000 After Denying A Couple’s Backyard Fence For Their Children With Special Needs, Then Each Homeowner Is Told To Pay $1,350 And 55 Neighbors Still Have Not, So The Couple Sues Again
  • Homeowners Say A Charismatic Renovator Collected Big Deposits, Gutted Their Homes To The Studs And Left Subcontractors Unpaid, And Court Records Show Nearly 70 Lawsuits Even After The State Suspended His Registration
  • Woman Pays A Contractor $38,480 In Four Checks For Home Repairs, Then A Probable Cause Statement Says He Removed Structural Supports, Left A Hole In The Roof And Claimed He Replaced Footings A Second Contractor Found He Did Not

Willow and Hearth

Willow and Hearth is your trusted companion for creating a beautiful, welcoming home and garden. From inspired seasonal décor and elegant DIY projects to timeless gardening tips and comforting home recipes, our content blends style, practicality, and warmth. Whether you’re curating a cozy living space or nurturing a blooming backyard, we’re here to help you make every corner feel like home.

Contact us at:
[email protected]

    • About
    • Blog
    • Contact Us
    • Editorial Policy
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions

© 2025 Willow and Hearth