Over two years, a house in an Edmond, Oklahoma neighborhood welcomed 141 guests during 36 short stays. On Tuesday, November 10, 2026, the Oklahoma Supreme Court decided by a 5 to 4 vote that this was a business, and that the owner must stop.

The case, Silverhawk Homeowners Association, Inc. v. Tawose, ended with the court restoring a trial judgment for the homeowners association, including $8,528 in fines and assessments. It is a closely watched ruling for anyone who lives under an HOA.
Owner Bought In 2015, Then Started Advertising Short Stays
The homeowner named in the opinion is Adewale Eniola Tawose. He bought the home in 2015 and later began advertising it for short stays. Evidence in the case showed 36 stays and 141 guests between late 2021 and late 2023.
The Silverhawk homeowners association sued him in November 2021, asking the court to stop the rentals and award damages, including for alleged nuisance. According to one report, the neighborhood is in Edmond, Oklahoma County.
The HOA board had contacted several homeowners it believed were running short-term rentals and asked them to stop. According to a description of the opinion, two owners agreed and converted their homes to long-term rentals. Tawose refused, arguing he had the right to use his property as he wished.
Six Words In The Covenant Became The Whole Fight
The neighborhood’s Declaration of Covenants, Conditions and Restrictions says lots may be used “for private residence purposes only.” It also prohibits a store or business from being maintained on a lot.
So the question for the courts was narrow. Does regularly renting a home to paying guests for a few days at a time count as a business under that language?
A Five-Day Trial Ended In The HOA’s Favor
The district court of Oklahoma County held a five-day trial and ruled for the association. It found the short-term rental violated the covenants.
It also found that some guests’ late-night gatherings and disruptive behavior amounted to a nuisance, and it rejected Tawose’s breach-of-contract counterclaim against the HOA. The judge cited the rental’s check-in and check-out times, the services and supplies provided to guests, and the hotel and motel taxes tied to the operation.
The judge ordered him to stop operating the rental and to pay $8,528 in HOA fines and assessments that had built up under the association’s rules.
Then The Appeals Court Flipped It, And The HOA Went Higher
Tawose appealed, and a panel of the Court of Civil Appeals reversed parts of the judgment and sent the case back for further proceedings. According to one report, that court found that short-term rentals did not necessarily change the residential nature of a property and could resemble having guests stay at a home.
It also considered the argument that collecting rent did not automatically turn the use into a commercial business under the Silverhawk wording. The HOA then asked the Oklahoma Supreme Court to step in.
Supreme Court Says It Looks More Like A Hotel Than A Home
By a 5 to 4 vote, the Supreme Court vacated the appeals court opinion and reinstated the district court judgment. It concluded that Tawose’s rental operation was a commercial use barred by the covenant’s language.
According to one report of the court’s findings, the justices pointed to details that made the operation look more like a hotel or motel than an ordinary home:
- Set check-in and check-out times.
- Basic items supplied to guests.
- Cleaning between stays.
- A cleaner who helped manage the property and answer guest questions.
- The owner’s retained right to enter the property.
Tawose disputed some of this evidence. The affirmed judgment includes the injunction barring him from operating the rental and $8,528 in damages based on fines and assessments. The attorney fee award was left in place because the court found Tawose had not properly preserved his challenge to it.
Four Justices Dissent: Guests Still Use A Home As A Residence
The vote was close. Four justices dissented, arguing the covenant’s business ban did not clearly prohibit short-term rentals and that guests use the home as a residence no matter how short the stay.
Their view, as reported, was that communities can prohibit short-term rentals but must do so in clear language in their covenants. That argument is likely to be heard again in other neighborhoods.
What The Ruling Means, And What It Does Not
One report says the high court’s reasoning is that an HOA can use its covenants to stop short-term rentals as long as the specific language supporting such a ban is in the neighborhood’s governing documents.
The same report stresses that the ruling concerns the specific wording of Silverhawk’s covenants. It does not mean every HOA in Oklahoma can prohibit short-term rentals. It depends on each neighborhood’s language.
City rules are a separate matter. Another report notes that Edmond’s city page lists vacation rental homes as not requiring a permit or license. That does not override a private covenant that homeowners agreed to when they bought.
Practical Steps If You Own Or Live Near A Rental Home
Short-term rentals booked through online platforms have set off disputes between owners who want income from their homes and neighbors who bought into a residential community. This ruling gives Oklahoma HOAs with similar “private residence only” and “no business” language a strong court precedent.
If you are thinking about renting out your home, or you are bothered by a neighbor who does, a few steps are worth taking:
- Read your declaration of covenants before you list a property, and look for phrases like “residence only” or bans on business use.
- Do not assume a city permit, or the lack of one, settles the question. Private covenants are a separate layer of rules.
- If you are on a board, consider spelling out your short-term rental policy in plain words rather than leaning on general language.
- If you receive a letter from your HOA, respond in writing and keep copies, since fines can add up over months.
The 5 to 4 split shows how close the question was and how much depends on clear drafting. In Silverhawk, the wording carried the day, and it cost one owner $8,528 and the right to keep hosting guests.
More Stories You May Like
- Homeowner Explains Why Buying In An HOA Neighborhood Means Mandatory Dues And Rules Plus A $150 Ticket For Long Grass, And Says He Would Never Live In One
- Homeowner Digs Up His Own Yard Hunting A Leak Behind $19,000 Water Bills, Then Finds The Seller’s Supposed Replacement Line Was The Problem
- Yard Guy Mows A Wildly Overgrown Lawn For Free Over 4 Days, Gets Kicked Off The Property, Then Learns The Homeowner Is Threatening To Sue Him
Leave a Reply