Willow and Hearth

  • Grow
  • Home
  • Style
  • Feast
CONTACT US
Modern home with a pool and outdoor seating area
Home & Harmony

Homeowner Keeps Asking Their Pool Contractor For Proof Of A Building Permit, Gets A Forged One After Months Of Questions, And The Contractor And His Company Now Plead Guilty

A homeowner on Long Island wanted one simple thing from the contractor building a pool in the backyard. They wanted to see the building permit.

Modern home with a pool and outdoor seating area

They kept asking, and the contractor kept stalling. When he finally produced a permit, it turned out to be a fake, and now he and his company have pleaded guilty.

According to the Suffolk County District Attorney’s office, a homeowner in Great River hired Robert Cortese, 39, and his company, Tool Time Construction Inc. of Huntington, in May 2021. The job was a pool and a pool house.

Months Of Questions About Proof The Work Was Approved

As the project moved along, the homeowner repeatedly asked for proof that the work had been approved. That is a fair question to ask anyone digging a hole and pouring concrete on your property.

A permit is how a town confirms that plans meet local safety and building rules. It is also what protects you later when you try to sell, insure or inspect what was built.

The homeowner did not let the question drop, and that persistence is what makes this story worth reading.

In October 2021, He Handed Over A “Town Of Islip” Building Permit

In October 2021, after those repeated requests, prosecutors say Cortese presented what he said was a Town of Islip building permit. It looked like the real thing on paper.

It was not. Prosecutors say the permit was forged, and that the work had never even been submitted to the town for approval.

Think about what that means. For months, the homeowner was told everything was in order, while the paperwork that was supposed to make the project legal did not exist.

The Contractor And His Company Plead Guilty To Possessing A Forged Instrument

The case ended in guilty pleas. Cortese and Tool Time Construction Inc. both pleaded guilty to criminal possession of a forged instrument, according to the District Attorney’s office.

The company’s name might sound friendly, but the charge is a serious criminal one. It is the legal term for holding a fake document that is meant to pass as real.

The District Attorney urged homeowners to confirm permits with their town building department. It is the kind of advice that costs nothing and could save you a fortune.

Why A Piece Of Paper From The Contractor Is Not Enough

This case is a lesson in why you should never take a contractor’s word, or a contractor’s paper, as the final answer. A permit is a public record, and the office that issues it can tell you whether it is real.

A contractor who is doing everything right will not mind that you check. In fact, honest builders are usually happy to point you to the right office, because it protects them as well.

The homeowner here asked the right question and kept asking. That habit is the best defense a homeowner has.

How To Check A Building Permit Before The First Shovel Goes In

Every town runs its building department a little differently, but the basic steps are similar. Here is a simple routine you can follow before a big project starts.

  • Ask the contractor which permits the job requires and who is pulling them.
  • Call or visit your town building department yourself and ask whether a permit has been filed for your address.
  • Ask for the permit number and the date it was issued, and confirm both with the town.
  • Get a copy of the permit and keep it with your contract and payment records.
  • Post the permit where the town expects it, and expect inspections at set stages of the work.
  • Do not pay large sums on promises. Tie payments to completed stages of work.

Warning Signs That Deserve A Second Look

Plenty of problems start with a small bit of hesitation, so pay attention to how a contractor reacts when you bring up permits. Vague answers, delays and changing stories should make you stop and check.

Be wary of anyone who tells you permits are not needed for a big project like a pool, or who offers to skip them to save you money. Work done without approval can cause trouble with the town, with insurance and with a future buyer.

Check on the contractor’s licensing too, using your local or state rules, since requirements differ from place to place.

The Takeaway For Homeowners Planning A Big Project

A homeowner in Great River hired a contractor in May 2021, asked repeatedly for proof the work was approved, and was handed a forged Town of Islip permit in October. That persistence helped bring the case to a point where the contractor and his company have pleaded guilty.

If you are planning a pool, an addition or any major build, make one call to your own town building department before you hand over a deposit. It takes a few minutes, and it is the cheapest insurance in home improvement.

Ask the questions, verify the answers yourself and keep asking until you are satisfied. Your home is too big an investment to run on trust alone.

More Stories You May Like

  • Unlicensed Contractor Who Told Customers He Was Licensed Is Banned From Minnesota Construction For Good And Hit With A $1.1 Million Judgment After Faking A Supplier Invoice
  • Utah Now Tops The Nation With 4.45% Of Homeowner Policies Dropped By Insurers, About 1 In 22, After Ranking 17th Worst A Year Earlier While California Sits Second At 2.93%
  • Home Prices Fall Year Over Year For The First Time Since 2023 As Mortgage Rates Above 7% Push Pending Sales To Their Lowest Level Since 2013
←Previous

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search

Categories

  • DIY & Repair
  • Feast & Festivity
  • Gather & Grow
  • Home & Harmony
  • Home Improvement & Renovation
  • Home Maintenance & Seasonal Prep
  • Home Safety & Recalls
  • Money-Saving Home Hacks
  • Style & Sanctuary
  • Tools & Gear
  • Trending
  • Uncategorized

Archives

  • November 2026
  • October 2026
  • September 2026
  • August 2026
  • July 2026
  • June 2026
  • May 2026
  • April 2026
  • March 2026
  • February 2026
  • January 2026
  • December 2025
  • November 2025
  • October 2025
  • July 2025
  • June 2025
  • March 2025

Latest Post

  • Homeowner Keeps Asking Their Pool Contractor For Proof Of A Building Permit, Gets A Forged One After Months Of Questions, And The Contractor And His Company Now Plead Guilty
  • Homeowner Waits A Year For A $1,750 Garage Roof Deposit Refund From A Contractor Who Never Started The Job, And The Contractor Says ‘You Have To Take Me To Civil Court’
  • Former Realtor Teams Up With Two Other Realtors To Get Around Client Commission Agreements On Eight Home Sales, Then The Regulator Says He Deleted Emails, Lied To Investigators And Must Pay $627,000

Willow and Hearth

Willow and Hearth is your trusted companion for creating a beautiful, welcoming home and garden. From inspired seasonal décor and elegant DIY projects to timeless gardening tips and comforting home recipes, our content blends style, practicality, and warmth. Whether you’re curating a cozy living space or nurturing a blooming backyard, we’re here to help you make every corner feel like home.

Contact us at:
[email protected]

    • About
    • Blog
    • Contact Us
    • Editorial Policy
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions

© 2025 Willow and Hearth