Tom Orsi of Woodridge, Illinois, says he has been waiting a full year to get back a $1,750 deposit for a garage roof replacement that never even started. When he asked for his money, he says, the contractor told him to sue.

Orsi is one of five suburban Chicago homeowners who told a Chicago television investigation that they paid deposits to Peter Valez of PRV 2 Certified LLC, based in Lemont, and ended up with unfinished work or work that never began. Valez disputes their accounts and blames the customers.
Five Homeowners Found The Same Contractor On Nextdoor
All of the homeowners in the report say they found Valez through the neighborhood website Nextdoor. They say they paid deposits for home improvement jobs and then got unfinished work or work that never started.
Several have filed police reports and paid new contractors to complete their projects. The report says Nextdoor had not yet responded to questions about whether Valez is still operating on its platform.
“I Just Feel Cheated”: A Year Without A Garage Roof Or A Refund
Orsi says the garage roof job never started. “I just feel cheated,” he said. “I just want to ask him why he thinks that he can get away with doing this to people.”
Orsi did recover $3,300 for materials after filing a fraud claim with his bank. He also filed a report with the Woodridge Police Department, and the police chief confirmed there is an open investigation.
Valez blamed scheduling conflicts on Orsi before admitting there were delays, including what he called weather delays, which led Orsi to demand a refund. Valez said: “There is a 500-dollar cancelation fee. He refused to accept it. If you think you owe me anything you have to take me to civil court.”
A Toilet In The Hallway And A Bathroom That Was One Third Done
Denise Davern, also of Woodridge, says she paid more than $3,000 in deposits in March for a bathroom remodel. She says only about a third of the job was completed.
According to Davern, Valez blamed her because he tried to keep working while she was on vacation. “Then he ghosted me and then like the days just kept going and I was waiting, you know, like I have a toilet in my hallway, like an inoperable bathroom,” she said.
Valez defended pausing the project: “I already told you that if you want a vacation in the middle of a remodel, then you are going to be put on hold until we complete this next customer. Okay.”
Kitchen, Drain Tile And Deck Disputes Follow The Same Pattern
In Naperville, Meredith Fockens and her husband, Randall, hired Valez in February for a kitchen remodel and paid a $3,300 down payment. Meredith Fockens said that quickly after paying, every time he set a date he would either not show up or call late the night before with an excuse.
Valez said the Fockenses were not being patient and that delays came from building custom cabinets. “It’s not like we can smack 12 cabinets together overnight or one week. It takes time,” he said. Naperville police said the case is now a civil matter.
In Orland Park, Andree Stanojevic paid Valez $600 in May to install a drain tile. Stanojevic said he promised to come Thursday, then Friday, and “same story never showed up.” Valez says Stanojevic’s dog bit him and that Stanojevic refused to pay his hospital bills. Stanojevic says the dog did not break Valez’s skin, and no documentation of injuries or medical treatment was produced.
In Indian Head Park, Steven O’Mahoney hired Valez in May to build a deck and paid $2,500 in deposits. “I fired him because the work was wrong, he was wanting to move forward with the wrong work,” O’Mahoney said.
A village inspection report noted that the “contractor deviated from the village approved plans” and that “posts are not properly secured to the piers.” Valez said an earlier inspection on the job had passed, and he said O’Mahoney told him he wanted another contractor because of bad reviews.
The Records: An F Rating, Five Complaints And A Dissolved LLC
Valez also disputed three additional complaints from consumers who did not appear on camera. Records cited in the report show the Illinois Attorney General’s office has received five complaints from the consumers featured.
PRV 2 Certified LLC holds an “F” rating with the Better Business Bureau for four unanswered complaints. Illinois Secretary of State records show an involuntary dissolution of the LLC.
No criminal charges against Valez have been reported. The only official confirmation of police activity is the open investigation in Woodridge and Naperville police calling its case civil.
The Contractor Says He Closed The Company And Opened Another
Valez told the reporter: “I spoke to about five different police departments, five different detectives. And because of all of this action, we allowed the company to actually close down. And we just opened up one under another name.”
When asked for the new company’s name he replied, “That’s not important,” and said he would not share it. The station found no new companies listed under Valez’s name. Valez also said that in some cases customers have not returned his tools.
What Homeowners Can Do Before And After Paying A Deposit
The deposits named in the report add up to a mix of small and large amounts: $1,750, more than $3,000, $3,300, $600 and $2,500. None is huge on its own, but for a household each one hurts, and the story shows how slowly things can move once the money is gone.
Refunds can take a year, police may treat a dispute as a civil matter, and a bank fraud claim was the route one homeowner used to get money back. A few general precautions can help:
- Check a contractor’s business status with the Illinois Secretary of State and look up complaint records before you pay anything.
- Keep deposits small and tie further payments to finished stages of the work.
- Get the start date, the cancellation terms and any fees in writing before you sign.
- Pay by a method that gives you recourse, such as a credit card, and contact your bank quickly if work never begins.
- Keep every text, email and photo, because civil court is where many of these disputes end up.
Valez says the delays are the customers’ fault. The homeowners say they are out money and still waiting. Either way, the best protection is the one you take before the deposit leaves your account.
More Stories You May Like
- Homeowner Quoted $100,000 To Restore The Wood In Her 1888 Victorian Strips It Herself And Says $200 In Materials Made It Worth Every Mistake
- Raleigh Homeowner Who Paid $1,900 For Off-Duty Officers Was Told His Halloween House Needs A Special Event Permit And Says My House Is Not A Special Event
- Homeowner With About 60,000 Synchronized Christmas Lights Is Fined $100 And Sues His HOA After It Rejected His Offer To Run At 30% Brightness
Leave a Reply